Defender Copy Dispute: JLR Loses the First Round Against BYD
A court in The Hague ordered Jaguar Land Rover to destroy digital files it seized from BYD's Dutch offices in a dispute over the BYD Ti7, a plug-in hybrid SUV that JLR calls a "slavish imitation" of the Land Rover Defender. The ruling came on 11 November, Auto Express reported on 12 November, and electrive added details on 14 November.

Key takeaways
- JLR had bailiffs secure files at BYD offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp in August, without warning BYD.
- The court lifted the measure in November 2026 and ordered the data destroyed, with a penalty of 50,000 euros per hour, capped at 500,000 euros.
- Under the November 2026 ruling JLR must also reimburse BYD for 25,376.57 euros in legal costs.
- The copying allegations themselves are still to be decided in separate cases.
What the Dutch court decided in JLR vs BYD
JLR obtained an evidence preservation order in August, and bailiffs secured documents that reportedly covered the development of the Ti7 as well as company financial data. BYD's lawyers called the raid a "fishing expedition" and objected that it captured many confidential files unrelated to the dispute. The court agreed that the seizure was not needed to prove the alleged design infringement, and not needed to assess damages either, because the Ti7 is not yet sold in the EU. It found that BYD had met its obligations to cooperate, and the November 2026 ruling refused JLR the 500,000 euros it had sought.
The main proceedings continue: a case in The Hague concerns EU design rights in the Land Rover Defender, and one in Rotterdam deals with copyright and alleged unfair imitation. JLR also claims that BYD took a Defender apart to reverse-engineer it. Both companies declined to comment, citing the ongoing proceedings, and no infringement has been proven.
BYD Ti7 specs and UK price against the Defender
The Ti7 has been on sale in China since September 2025 under BYD's Fang Cheng Bao brand. Its angular body, upright front and square wheel arches echo the Defender, and at around 5 metres it is close in length to the Defender 110. The plug-in hybrid combines a 1.5-litre turbo petrol engine with electric motors for a system output of 300 kW (about 402 hp), and a 35.6 kWh battery gives up to 119 km (74 miles) of electric range on the WLTP cycle.
BYD plans to launch the Ti7 in the UK as a seven-seater in January 2027, priced from GBP 47,995 in 2027 according to electrive. The cheapest seven-seat Defender 110 costs GBP 68,465 in 2026, about GBP 20,000 more.
JLR and earlier Chinese copy cases
JLR has fought similar battles before. In 2019 it won a case in China against Jiangling Motor over the Landwind X7, a near replica of the Range Rover Evoque. It also works with a Chinese partner by choice: its joint venture with Chery, in place since 2014, now runs the Freelander brand created in 2024, whose resemblance to JLR models is deliberate and legal.
What happens next
For UK buyers, the ruling does not stop the Ti7 launch, and the outcome of the design and copyright cases in the Netherlands will decide whether BYD can sell it in the EU unchanged.
Sources
- Auto Express: Jaguar Land Rover vs BYD: British firm ordered to destroy seized data in Defender copycat case (12 Nov 2026) (accessed 18 Nov 2026)
- electrive: Legal proceedings should establish whether the BYD Ti7 is a Copy of JLR's Defender (14 Nov 2026) (accessed 18 Nov 2026)
Found a mistake? Report an error




